Guide · Home insurance
Replacement cost vs. actual cash value
The valuation method in your policy changes how much a claim pays. It is one of the most important lines to understand before you need it.
4 min read · Last reviewed 2026-10
The difference in one sentence
Replacement cost generally pays what it costs to replace the damaged item with a new, similar one, while actual cash value subtracts depreciation for age and wear. Your policy states which method applies to which items.
Where the choice matters most
- The dwelling itself, where a replacement cost basis is meant to cover rebuilding.
- Personal property, where policies often default to actual cash value unless you add replacement cost coverage.
- Some policies treat certain items, such as roofs, differently. Ask how yours does.
What to ask
- Which method applies to my dwelling and to my belongings?
- Are there limits or conditions, such as repairing or replacing the item before I am paid in full?
- How much would adding replacement cost for belongings change my premium?
Questions
Is replacement cost always better?
It usually pays more after a loss, and it can cost more. The right choice depends on the value of your property and your budget.
Where do I find the valuation method?
On your policy's declarations page and in the loss settlement section of the policy.
Sources
- NAIC: Publications (includes the Consumer's Guide to Homeowners Insurance)
- NAIC: State insurance department directory
Informational only. Rules and policy terms change and differ by state and insurer. Confirm details with your policy, your insurer or your state insurance department.
Related guides
Back to home insurance.
See the full topic page, your state summary and every guide in this cluster.